The epic Welsh win over the All Blacks that headlined the fifth round of the Nations Championship has played the Springboks back into strong contention for a place in the main game in the Finals Weekend in London, but it hasn’t changed what Siya Kolisi’s team needs to do.
When it was suggested to him by a television interviewer after his world champion side lost 21-19 to France in Paris if he was looking forward to a possible rematch with the French in the grand final, Kolisi was clear that he wasn’t looking that far ahead. The sole focus must now be on beating Ireland in Dublin on Saturday. And he’s right.
As it turns out the All Blacks did do enough in their loss in Cardiff to profit from the Paris result by edging ahead on the southern log. By losing 35-28 they were able to pick up a bonus point for being within seven points to go with their four try bonus point.
So it is New Zealand 22 and South Africa 21 as we head into the final round of the inaugural Championship.
Whereas the northern log is a bit of a log jam going into the sixth round, with three nations in contention to finish top and thus secure a place in the main final, the All Blacks and Boks are out on their own in the southern half.
But the one-point advantage the Kiwis enjoy is significant as it means that making the final will be beyond the Boks if the All Blacks win with a bonus point against England in London.
The Twickenham game will be played immediately before the Boks kick off at the Aviva Stadium so the South Africans will know what they need when the game starts. But the possibility they will be playing just to confirm second spot on the log will not deflect coach Rassie Erasmus and Kolisi from their mission this week.
IT IS REALLY ALL ABOUT MOMENTUM AHEAD OF RWC YEAR
The Championship is arguably a bit gimmicky anyway, introduced to give more relevance to the international games played at this time of the year and in July. What is really important right now is that the competing coaches get what they need in this last fortnight of the penultimate year of this World Cup cycle.
What this all means to the RWC buildup may just be more important than who finishes where, and the Boks need to win the two remaining games, regardless of whether the last one is a final or not, so they can end the year with some momentum. They don’t want to start the buildup to the RWC next year having lost two or even three of the games that finished their previous year.
Winning the Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry series was the main mission for the Boks this year, and they achieved that objective. But since then they’ve dropped two in three games.
There was context to the loss in Perth, although that is undermined every time the Wallabies play and show how weak they’ve become, and losing to France in Paris isn’t a disgrace.
FRANCE HAVE SIMILAR DEPTH TO SOUTH AFRICA
The French are one of the big three, the other being New Zealand, and like South Africa they have the depth to cover for injuries. The Boks were significantly off their game at Stade de France, but they still dominated the last 45 minutes of the game and would have at least drawn the match were it not for Manie Libbok’s miss of the conversion to Malcolm Marx’s try seven minutes from time.
The France win was arguably more about them, meaning good for France, than it was bad for the Boks, who will know that they were dominant physically after the opening half hour and that to a large extent they conspired against themselves. And just for some context - the Boks, in the 2023 RWC quarterfinal and in their game last year, remain the only visiting team to have won in Paris since the start of 2023.
That point about the Boks conspiring against themselves, if you accept it, is perhaps what should be of most concern - for it was far from the only time it has happened. If you go back to the games the Boks have lost in this World Cup cycle, most of them have been a case of the world champions playing against themselves as much as the opposition beating them.
It happened in Johannesburg against Australia last year and at Eden Park against the All Blacks, it happened against the All Blacks in Johannesburg at the start of the RGR series.
And it happened again in Paris, with a lack of accuracy and then a failure to convert massive dominance in the scrums and mauls making the game very reminiscent of the one that the All Blacks won in Johannesburg.
With the All Blacks going down to Wales the following day, it could be argued that the weekend confirmed that the two biggest obstacles to the Boks and their ambitions are themselves and France.
FRENCH ARE THE BIGGER LONG TERM THREAT THAN KIWIS
That is not saying that France will be a bigger threat than New Zealand at next year’s World Cup, but is a reference to what surely should be the Boks’ long term ambition - which is to capitalise on the conveyor belt of talent coming through the systems at youth level by consistently being at the top.
The All Blacks will always be competitive, but the threats against rugby union in New Zealand that drove their complaints about the laws in the early stages of the RGR series are real and in time the All Blacks may slip some way behind the top two, South Africa and France.
The Cardiff result, given they had mixed up their selections, showed up the All Black lack of depth.
But there are immediate concerns that need to be addressed by Erasmus and his team, and while the Boks did hit target when they won the RGR, it is starting to look as though the growth that was on such a sharp upward trend on the graph this time last year might just be plateauing a bit.
In the sense that this time last year, when Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu was showing such promise of by now being the best No10 in the world, we might have imagined the Boks would be a bit further in their growth than they are right now.
It is important for the Boks to disprove that feeling of misgiving and that is what their two remaining matches of 2026 should be about. It will be interesting to see if Erasmus gets back onto his mission to improve depth ahead of the RWC in these next two games.
This may be a good time to mix up selections a bit, but we will know soon enough - Rassie is clear in his own mind, as reflected by the decision to announce the team for Dublin at lunch time on Monday.
