The Springboks are the one team in World Rugby that pride themselves on their scrum and use it as a fundamental attacking weapon, and while that isn’t universally popular in world rugby, perhaps the strategy needs a rethink.
Or perhaps not a rethink, but a tweak. And this isn’t a criticism of Daan Human’s exceptional coaching skills in the setpiece, nor the awesome power shown by the Springbok - and often South African front rows - in competitions they play in.
But rather a rethink in terms of when to use it and when not. On Friday night, in the midst of the tension at Stade de France, when the Boks were desperately looking to get ahead of the French and were dominating all facets with their forwards, there was a series of scrums on the French line that brought this point back to the frontline.
Cobus Reinach, the replacement scrumhalf, barked at his forwards - “skrum hulle na die doellyn toe” (Scrum them to the dead ball line). The intent was clear. The Boks were going to look for yellow cards, a pushover try or even a penalty try as they wanted to assert their dominance on the opposition, and were going to scrum through the French pack to do it.
But herein lies the rub. While rugby’s fundamental mindset tells you that when you have the opposition on the rack, you press your advantage home, it has become more and more apparent that referees don’t want to reward a totally dominant scrum, and this has now happened to the Boks three times.
SHOULDN'T BE A DISCUSSION
Now this isn’t what should be happening, and we all know it. If your opponent cannot hold his own in the scrum and infringes, he should be penalised, but we are now seeing a pattern emerging of referees not wanting to give endless scrum penalties and the criticism that comes with it.
It is no secret that there is a big part of the rugby world that feels the scrum should be taken out of the game. New Zealand’s troubles with Rugby League - for one - mean that they don’t want the scrum to be anything more than a reset, and we had endless debates about the scrum in Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry series, primarily because the All Blacks pushed it so hard.
Last year in the corresponding fixture in Dublin, the Springboks went all in to break Ireland’s resolve through the scrum. There were countless penalties and cards and eventually it became a bit too much for the referees.
Matthew Carley was the referee and while he was only refereeing the letter of the law and Ireland’s scrum had no answer to the Bok power, the vitriol that he received after the game, the criticism and the calls for the scrum to change all came ironically from sides that have struggled with the setpiece in recent times, but there was no end up north in debates on how the game needs to be played.
HAPPENED AT ELLIS PARK
Fast forward to the Boks first test in Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry against the All Blacks and the Boks had the All Blacks under the pump. They were on their own 5m line and the Boks were scrumming for a penalty try, a yellow card and total domination.
And somehow, Carley - perhaps remembering the criticism of the Dublin game - gave the All Blacks a scrum penalty. The shock was palpable at Ellis Park, especially after 55 000 people were chanting “scrum, scrum, scrum” and the Boks had the upper hand. But the Boks fell apart and the All Blacks scored late tries for a big win. And the die was set.
The less we speak about Angus Gardner’s abdication of the scrum in that second test, the better, but again against France Andrea Piardi warned France’s scrum multiple times before giving a yellow card. There were several warnings and when the pivotal scrum eventually came, he decided to “play on” despite another collapse.
It was a classical example of a referee in front of a baying crowd not wanting to be the villain. But it was also a lesson for the Boks going ahead.
WORLD CUP JEOPARDY
Picture the scene - a World Cup quarterfinal vs New Zealand or semifinal vs France, and a scrum in the same position. The Boks have a scrum on the five metre line and the same situation arises. There is a greater chance than ever that the referees nowadays, under pressure, don’t want to be seen as one who “ruins” a game with scrum penalties.
A trend has emerged. Reward the dominant scrum until you don’t. That may not be right, but it is something to take note of, especially when a World Cup is on the line.
How do the Boks solve it? In a game like Friday night’s a few shots at goal may have helped, but it is perhaps more a lesson on not getting over-reliant on a part of the game that can be so open to interpretation, so open to the whims of referees feeling the pressure and thinking ahead to the review.
A different approach may be needed. Keep the domination, and keep the psychological advantage, but realise they aren’t going to reward total dominance. And make sure when it does, it counts.
It sounds simple, but perhaps not so. The Boks are always going to want to get that ascendancy, that psychological edge and the scrum is the perfect spot to do it.
But they need to box clever, or this trend that has happened three times in a year may become a more permanent affair.
